← Editorials

Summaries by Anurag Behar

13 summaries by this author.

Critical

Why artificial intelligence could be the last blow to higher education in India

India’s higher education is profoundly dysfunctional, worse than its schools, plagued by neglect. Empty classrooms, absent faculty, minimal expectations prevail. Failures go unnoticed due to absent learning metrics. Issues include unclear teaching objectives, flawed teaching-research conflation, and tacit teacher-student disengagement. Institutions resist reform; public funding shortfalls fuel damaging commercialization. AI is a critical threat, potentially hollowing out learning. While some excel, the majority fails. Urgent, foundational change is crucial to avert AI’s "death blow".

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Nov 11, 2026 at 7:00 AM

Full summary →
Critical

Azim Premji Foundation CEO: How schools can help build a more humane world for everyone

The author critiques the "markets solve everything" paradigm, particularly its failure in education where private schools often lack proven advantages over public ones. This ideology overlooks economic realities like information asymmetry and, crucially, humanity's inherent goodness. Evidence from animal behavior and neuroscience demonstrates humans are evolutionarily built for care, not just self-interest. Current systems amplify self-interest; thus, we must redesign our world. School education is vital in fostering humility, cooperation, and responsibility, allowing our full nature, including goodness, to thrive for a more humane society.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Oct 28, 2026 at 7:00 AM

Full summary →
Critical

Open minds please: School can't teach children everything but must foster lifelong learning

Scientific orthodoxies about animal capabilities, such as tool-making or complex thought, have been consistently overturned by new research. Examples like Jane Goodall's chimpanzees, capuchin monkey fairness, and elephant naming demonstrate how previous certainties were confidently wrong. The author advocates for intellectual humility, open-mindedness, and interdisciplinary learning, arguing that knowledge advances by challenging settled beliefs. Education must foster a continuous learning disposition and curiosity, rather than rigid content. This approach, acknowledging the partiality of our understanding, extends to human relations, promoting a more humane world by questioning assumptions about others.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Oct 14, 2026 at 6:30 AM

Full summary →
Critical

Oracles of AI are gambling with the future of children, workers and others. Why let them?

The author critically warns that AI stunts children's cognitive development by outsourcing mental work, preventing fundamental understanding, especially in math. This "hollowing out" of thinking skills, coupled with significant job displacement, poses a severe threat. The article lambastes technologists and economists for dismissing these dangers, attributing their stances to self-interest and flawed perspectives. It argues that society is dangerously gambling with its future, allowing AI to undermine human intellect and employment without adequate caution.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Sep 30, 2026 at 7:00 AM

Full summary →
Critical

The OECD's school report obfuscates a global education emergency instead of raising the alarm—why?

The author criticizes the OECD's PISA 2025 report for minimizing a global education crisis, evident in plummeting reading and math scores. Despite data showing the lowest scores since 2000 across 91 countries, the report, titled “Future-Ready Students,” offers vague explanations. The author argues this avoids the most probable cause: widespread smartphone and AI use, which correlates with weaker performance and declining reading for pleasure. The article asserts the OECD has a moral duty to unequivocally name this crisis and prompt urgent action, rather than offering anodyne obfuscation. The current equivocation is an abdication of responsibility for failing a generation.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Sep 16, 2026 at 7:30 AM

Full summary →
Supportive

Why fewer state-run schools does not signal neglect of education: it’s learning that matters

India's government school "closures" reflect a positive reform, not neglect. Approximately 94,000 schools have been consolidated from small, inefficient, single-teacher institutions into fewer, better-staffed, and better-resourced facilities. This process, observed firsthand, significantly improves learning outcomes and teacher effectiveness, maintaining student access. Critics misinterpret data, overlooking positive ground-level changes enhancing public education. This overdue correction ensures children attend functional schools with improved quality, aligning with National Education Policy goals.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Sep 2, 2026 at 6:30 AM

Full summary →
Critical

School children shouldn’t have to pay the price for untenable orthodoxies about learning

The Continuous Comprehensive Evaluation (CCE) and no-detention policy, though conceptually sound, became a failed orthodoxy in Indian schooling. Intended to eliminate exam burdens, its impractical implementation overstretched teachers, leading to superficial record-keeping without genuine assessment. This created a generation of students who advanced without adequate learning, only to face concentrated failure at age 15. The system disproportionately harmed underprivileged children lacking external support. The author critically argues that abstract educational ideals, unchecked by classroom realities, caused immense damage, proving a costly experiment for millions of students.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Aug 19, 2026 at 6:31 AM

Full summary →
Critical

Children must not be deprived of real learning in the process of trying to make education fun

The author critiques the "joyful learning" dogma, initially well-intentioned, now an oversimplified foundation in Indian education. Prioritizing "lightness" over effort, it fostered misguided methods, hindering true learning. Genuine learning involves struggle, effort, and overcoming frustration; real joy is earned. Equating difficulty with oppression particularly harms disadvantaged children, denying rigorous education. The article argues that true educational joy is hard-won, not guaranteed or effortless, stressing the distinction between lifting unnecessary burdens and demanding effort crucial for deep understanding.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Aug 5, 2026 at 7:00 AM

Full summary →
Critical

Learning to read: why faulty theories should not be allowed to get in the way of primary education

The author critically refutes the "whole language" reading approach, which advocates immersion over explicit phonics, branding it a damaging dogma. This theory, falsely equating reading to natural speech acquisition, led to educational failures, notably in the US. Scientific research unequivocally shows skilled readers decode explicitly; guessing is a poor reader's habit. Fortunately, Indian schools are now adopting systematic, explicit code teaching, especially suitable for transparent Indian scripts. The author stresses that evidence-based pedagogy, prioritizing explicit decoding as the means to comprehension, is essential, warning against unproven educational abstractions.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Jul 22, 2026 at 6:30 AM

Full summary →
Critical

Children's schooling has swung from one dogma to another: here’s what to watch out for

The article critically examines how progressive education's misapplied constructivism often proves regressive. It highlights the "constructivist teaching fallacy," confusing physical activity with cognitive engagement, thereby hindering genuine student understanding. The author argues that while constructivism, as a theory, is broadly correct, its rigid interpretation as doctrine harms learning, particularly for first-generation students needing explicit guidance. Effective teaching, it concludes, demands judicious assessment and tailored instruction over strict adherence to any doctrine, emphasizing professional judgment for optimal outcomes, not just activity.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Jul 8, 2026 at 6:31 AM

Full summary →
Balanced

Azim Premji Foundation CEO: how donors behave shapes key outcomes in the not-for-profit sector

The Azim Premji Foundation's CEO critically examines donor weaknesses within India's social sector. The article highlights five key flaws: favoring well-funded NPOs over smaller ones, excessive due diligence burdens, donors' superior attitude, inadequate funding for NPO organizational capacity, and past adherence to "donor delusions" like scale and sustainability. The author emphasizes the power imbalance and calls for greater self-awareness and improved practices. While some issues are partially addressed, donors must continually refine their approach to better support the not-for-profit ecosystem and foster genuine strength.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · Jun 24, 2026 at 6:30 AM

Full summary →
Supportive

Education in the age of AI: sharpen human faculties like critical thinking, don’t stuff students with facts

School education, especially in classes 6-12, faces a significant problem of curriculum overload, leading to rote memorization rather than genuine understanding and critical thinking. As human knowledge expands, curricula become denser, forcing students into shallow learning. Reforms like India's NEP 2020 and NCF 2023 aim to shift from content transmission to competency development and reduce the content load, promoting deeper engagement. However, implementation is slow, facing resistance from teachers, parents, and curriculum designers reluctant to reduce subjects. The author argues that less content, taught effectively, builds essential learning capacities, which is the true purpose of education, requiring focused practical execution.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · May 27, 2026 at 6:30 AM

Full summary →
Critical

India’s emergence has a deficit that may not be too late for us to collectively close—empathy

India's affluent often overlook stark urban dichotomies, especially in Bengaluru, where immense tech wealth coexists with dire poverty. This divide isn't merely policy failure but a collective empathy deficit among the privileged. The author highlights a dedicated teacher who transformed her village through education, demonstrating powerful individual agency. The text contrasts gleaming private sports facilities with adjacent slums, whose residents endure unbearable conditions. The author argues that individual engagement with these overlooked realities, rather than apathy, is vital for societal improvement and personal growth.

LiveMint · Anurag Behar · May 13, 2026 at 7:01 AM

Full summary →